The Cleveland Browns have hit their well-timed bye week, and as expected, the quarterbacks are top of mind as we begin to look ahead to the final seven games of the regular season.
But we’re no longer discussing Deshaun Watson vs. Shedeur Sanders. That debate was put to bed on Sunday, when Watson improved to 6-3 as a starter this season and mounted his sixth game-winning drive in a comeback win over the Houston Texans.
The discussion now has shifted to Watson’s contract, which is set to expire via a post-June 1 cut designation in March of 2027. That’s been the plan since December of 2024, when the Browns reworked Watson’s fully-guaranteed contract following his first Achilles surgery.
And that remains the most plausible path forward for both sides, as a post-June 1 release would allow the Browns to break up Watson’s dead money — salary cap charges of $34.6 million in 2027 and $51.4 million in 2028, per Over the Cap — over two seasons. Doing so would finally free them from arguably the worst contract in NFL history.
But door No. 2 — some form of contract extension prior to March that pushes Watson’s dead-cap hits farther down the road — becomes more possible with each Browns win, and Spotrac’s Matt Ginnitti just broke down how taking that path could work.
“An ideal extension for Deshaun Watson right now could be a two-year, $36 million contract, including $18 million guaranteed at signing," Ginnitti wrote. "The deal provides a flat $18 million in cash compensation for both 2027 and 2028, structured around minimum base salaries and a $16.6 million signing bonus in 2027, followed by a $16.6 million option bonus in 2028.”
Browns' Deshaun Watson contract decision may already be out of their hands
Ginnitti’s full breakdown is fascinating and well worth a read. It’s essentially a full commitment to Watson in 2027 as another bridge year, with him earning $18 million in cash with a $39.3 million cap hit. Ginnitti includes a potential out in 2028, which would leave Cleveland with $64.8 million in dead cap to absorb if he’s no longer on the roster.
It’s a similar take to the one Browns cap expert Jack Duffin of the Orange and Brown Report had earlier this year. He projected a one-year, $7 million extension as a baseline for typical bridge QB deals.
“Past money that was paid in base salary, restructures, options bonus etc doesn't change,” Duffin wrote. “The salary cap cost in 2027 and 2028 go up by $7m in total.”
So what the experts are essentially saying is that the potential for a Watson extension is very possible — it would just come down to the player accepting substantially less money.
Watson was once one of the best quarterbacks in football. He’s been earning comfortably within the top 10 QBs in terms of real cash for the balance of his deal with the Browns, which was signed in 2022.
He’s been making $46 million per year on average. So we're talking about a player who believes he’s resurrecting his career in real time accepting around $30 million less for the 2027 season. Using Ginnitti’s calculus, he'd be accepting a flat rate of $18 million for each of the next two seasons. He'd be doing so at a time when Drake Maye and Caleb Williams could feasibly break the $70-million-per-year barrier.
It just doesn’t seem feasible.
Browns fans probably feel like Watson owes them one. Prior to this 2026 season, he started a whopping 19 games due to suspensions and injuries. The Browns only won nine of those games.
The guess here is that the player who sustained brutal shoulder and Achilles injuries, got booed by fans as he was carted off Huntington Bank Field in 2024, and heard his owner call acquiring him “a big swing and miss” after undergoing a second Achilles surgery in 2025, doesn’t feel like he owes Cleveland one cent.
As with any contract situation, it’s going to boil down to Watson’s market. Watson will likely only accept what another team is willing to pay him, and the best way to determine that number is to test free agency.
Yes, Cleveland will have exclusive negotiating rights with Watson prior to March. It’s definitely possible that the two sides agree to some sort of short-term extension.
But it would require him agreeing to a substantial pay cut before the poison pill in his contract — a clause that guarantees him $200 million in the 2029 season if he’s still on the roster on the third league day of 2027 — forces the Browns’ hand. It’s either a post-June 1 release or an extension before that date. There is no door No. 3 with how his contract was restructured.
The guess here is that it’s still Door No. 1. Had Watson and the Browns not rallied back from an early 17-0 deficit against the Texans on Sunday, no one would be talking about an extension. They’d be talking about the potential of Sanders being named the starter over the bye week and getting a full week to prepare for the Raiders on Nov. 29.
We’ve been walking a fine line here in Year 5 of the Watson experience. A mutual parting of ways remains the most likely scenario, although those odds have decreased much more than expected over these past 10 weeks.
